The term marginal tax rate is central to tax planning, budgeting, and financial decision-making, yet it is often misunderstood. This article gives a practical, step-by-step guide to what the marginal tax rate is, how it differs from your effective or average tax rate, why it matters for choices like taking a bonus or selling an asset, and how to calculate it with real examples.
The marginal tax rate is the rate of tax applied to the last dollar you earn. In other words, it answers the question: what percent of any additional dollar of income will be paid in tax? In progressive tax systems, income is taxed in brackets, so your marginal rate is the rate of the highest bracket that contains part of your income.
Definition: The marginal tax rate is the tax on the next dollar of income earned.
Confusion often arises between marginal and effective tax rates. They are not the same.
Marginal tax rate: The tax rate applied to your last dollar of income. It determines how additional income is taxed and influences decisions like working overtime, taking a bonus, or realizing investment gains.
Effective (average) tax rate: Your total tax paid divided by total taxable income. It shows the percent of your income that goes to tax overall, not the rate on the next dollar.
Example: If your taxable income is $75,000 and you pay $12,000 in tax, your effective tax rate is 12,000 / 75,000 = 16%. But your marginal rate might be 22% if the top dollar of your income sits in the 22% bracket.
Progressive tax systems divide income into brackets with different rates. Each bracket applies only to the income within its range, not to your entire income. This is the key reason marginal and effective rates differ.
Imagine three brackets: 0% on the first $10,000, 10% on the next $40,000, and 20% on income above $50,000. If you earn $60,000, the last $10,000 falls in the 20% bracket, so your marginal tax rate is 20%, even though large portions of your income were taxed at lower rates.
Your marginal rate affects many financial choices:
Work decisions: If overtime pay or a contract payment pushes income into a higher bracket, the marginal rate tells you how much of that extra pay you'll keep.
Savings and investments: The marginal rate is used to value tax deductions and credits. A deduction that reduces taxable income by $1 saves you tax equal to your marginal rate.
Retirement and withdrawals: When deciding between tax-deferred and tax-free retirement accounts, compare expected marginal rates now versus in retirement.
Capital gains and selling assets: In some jurisdictions, long-term gains may be taxed differently, but the marginal tax rate still helps determine the benefit of timing a sale.
Suppose your taxable income before a year-end bonus is $88,000 and the 24% bracket starts at $89,000. A $5,000 bonus means the first $1,000 of the bonus is taxed at 22% (your previous bracket) and the remaining $4,000 at 24%. The marginal rate on the last dollar is 24%.
Follow these steps to determine your marginal tax rate:
1. Determine taxable income: Start with adjusted gross income and subtract deductions and exemptions to get taxable income.
2. Consult current tax brackets: Use the tax brackets for your filing status and year. Brackets change annually and differ by jurisdiction.
3. Locate which bracket contains your taxable income: The rate for that bracket is your marginal tax rate.
Example calculation (simplified): Assume the following bracket structure for single filers: 10% to $10,000; 12% $10,001–$40,000; 22% $40,001–$85,000; 24% over $85,000. If your taxable income is $60,000, the marginal tax rate is 22% because $60,000 falls inside the 22% bracket.
If you have wages, interest, dividends, capital gains, or rental income, all taxable income aggregates to determine which bracket you occupy. Some types of income may receive preferential rates (for example long-term capital gains), and some credits or deductions may phase out at higher incomes, effectively increasing your marginal rate on additional income.
Important: Phaseouts and surtaxes can create effective marginal rates that are higher than the bracket rate because benefits (credits or deductions) shrink as income rises.
Myth: If I move into a higher bracket, all my income is taxed at that higher rate. This is false. Only the income inside the higher bracket is taxed at the higher rate. Your earlier income remains taxed at lower bracket rates.
Myth: My marginal rate is the only rate that matters. While critical for decisions about additional income, the effective tax rate and total tax liability matter for budgeting and long-term planning.
You cannot always change the statutory tax brackets, but you can influence your taxable income and the taxes you pay. Common strategies include:
Tax-advantaged retirement contributions: Pre-tax contributions reduce taxable income today, potentially lowering your marginal tax rate.
Tax-loss harvesting: Offsetting capital gains with losses can reduce taxable income exposed to higher marginal rates.
Flexible timing: Defer income to a later year if you expect to be in a lower marginal bracket or accelerate deductions into the current year to reduce taxable income.
Use of tax credits: Credits reduce tax liability dollar-for-dollar and can be more powerful than deductions for lowering effective tax burden.
Example A: Simple progressive system Suppose taxable income: $50,000. Brackets: 10% first $10,000; 15% next $30,000; 20% over $40,000. Tax is 10% of 10,000 = $1,000; 15% of 30,000 = $4,500; 20% of remaining 10,000 = $2,000. Total tax = $7,500. Effective tax rate = 7,500 / 50,000 = 15%. Marginal tax rate = 20% because the last dollars lie in the 20% bracket.
Example B: Effect of a deduction If you can contribute $5,000 to a pre-tax retirement account, taxable income drops from $50,000 to $45,000. With the same brackets, the portion taxed at 20% shrinks or disappears, lowering both your effective tax rate and possibly the marginal bracket that applies to future income.
Two factors can push your effective marginal cost of earning more above the nominal bracket rate:
Phaseouts and benefit reductions: Certain tax credits, deductions, or government benefits may phase out as income rises. The combined effect can make the marginal cost of income much higher than the bracket rate.
Payroll taxes and state taxes: For wage income, payroll taxes (like Social Security and Medicare in the U.S.) apply in addition to income tax. State or local taxes further increase the combined marginal rate.
1. The marginal tax rate is the tax on the next dollar you earn and is set by the tax bracket containing your income.
2. The effective tax rate reflects the total share of income paid in tax and is typically lower than the marginal rate in progressive systems.
3. Marginal rates matter for decisions about additional income, deductions, and timing of transactions.
4. Always consider phaseouts, payroll taxes, and state taxes when estimating your real marginal cost of income.
Tax brackets can change annually due to inflation adjustments, tax law changes, or policy reforms. Check the current tax year rules for the most accurate calculation.
Use your marginal tax rate to estimate the immediate tax savings from a deduction because it reduces taxable income that would otherwise be taxed at that marginal rate.
In rare cases, refundable tax credits can create a negative net tax on additional income across a narrow range, but this is not the same as a negative marginal rate in the standard progressive bracket sense.
Understanding your marginal tax rate empowers better financial choices. When planning major financial moves, run scenarios that combine marginal income tax with payroll taxes, state taxes, and any benefits or credits that could phase out. If your situation is complex, consult a tax professional who can model your marginal and effective rates precisely and recommend optimal strategies.
Armed with the distinction between marginal and effective rates and a clear calculation method, you can make smarter decisions about work, investments, and tax planning to keep more of what you earn.
Learn how to prepare, file, and correct T4 slips in Canada. Deadlines, box explanations, penalties, filing options and practical tips for employers and employees.
Learn MoreLearn how to read a CRA Notice of Assessment, what the key sections mean, steps to take if you disagree, payment options, and deadlines.
Learn MoreComprehensive guide to capital gains tax: definitions, short-term vs long-term rates, calculating gains, reporting rules, exclusions, and practical strategies to minimize taxes.
Learn MoreComprehensive guide to tax deductions and credits: learn differences, common tax breaks, eligibility rules, and smart strategies to reduce your federal tax bill.
Learn MoreComprehensive guide explaining what taxable income is, how it differs from gross income, what items are included and excluded, step-by-step calculation examples, and practical strategies to reduce taxable income legally.
Learn More
